Review - The new Outlook Express / Thunderbird Killer: Windows Live Mail (Desktop)

Posted Sunday, May 13, 2007 3:16 PM by Mischa Kroon

Ok, so what is Windows Live Mail Desktop ?

Windows Live Mail, formerly known as Windows Live Mail Desktop is the new Mail Client from Microsoft which is their replacement for Outlook Express (supplied with Windows XP) and Windows Mail (supplied with Vista). 

What does it do ? And how well does it do it ?

Well the same thing Outlook Express does only more :)

  • Synchronization with Windows Live Contacts
    • It uses the central contacts list you also use in Hotmail + Live Messenger (MSN), so update one of those and this will follow and vice versa, there is also a nice interface to manipulate your contacts with Avatars for better recognitino and extra information (contact also on Messenger etc.)
  • Support for RSS feeds, which requires and uses Internet Explorer 7's RSS capabilities, including the ability to reply directly via email to the author of an item that appears in an RSS feed, as well as multiple feed aggregation into a single folder
    • Haven't tried this out yet since I'm still a hold out on IE 7
  • The usage of Emoticons in e-mails and other functions
    • Some will call this a non feature but hey I like it :)
  • In-line spell checking
    • Always good to have a spell checker running :)
  • Separate inbox folders for different POP accounts
    •  It has seperate folders for your e-mail accounts by default but it also has a united folder for all email, this is just an extra way of getting to your e-mail faster.
  • SPAM / Phishing Filter
    • You know you want it :) It has been a bit too aggressive on my accounts but I don't really mind that too much. Just make sure you check your SPAM folder every now and then.
  • Blog integration
    • Haven't tried it out yet. My guess this is Live Spaces only
  • Reply with IM (MSN)
    • I like it especially when it's coupled with offline messaging, you can just reply to e-mails or the one who sent you the email by instant messaging which can be preferred especially when the person is online and you want a clarification or something else.
  • Really fast search in Emails
    • I missed this in Outlook / Outlook Express so much.
  • Minimize as tray icon function
    • Saves room in the taskbar + uses very little memory like that.
  • Good integration with Hotmail accounts
    • How I hate the slowness of the new Windows Live Hotmail interface compared to this nice desktop interface. No longer do I have to sort to get to the right email form 4 years back :P
  • Upgraded interface
    • It looks quite nice
  • Calendar integration
    • Online Live Calendar / Hotmail calendar integrated.
  • Import your settings from Outlook Express
    • A must have :)
  • Integration with Windows Live Messenger
    • Send IM's, view Avatars in the e-mail view pane
  • More intelligent show Images function
    • You already viewed the Image once, oh well then you don't have to say you want to view it the next time you open the e-mail
  • Use of color scheme's
    • Doesn't do much for me but I'm sure some others will like it :)

What's cool about it ?

All the things listed above :) and the fact that nobody seems to be talking about it yet :)

What isn't cool about it ?

  • It's memory usage can get a little high, I think 74 MB was my maximum usage, which is a bit much for a lightweigth e-mail client.
  • No direct support for Exchange Servers (Outlook only feature)
  •  It's still in Beta
  • It might get Ad supported :(
  • You have to log into it using what seems to be a passport account, this means one extra enter / mouse click on your part. (can be disabled in the settings)

Verdict

This will be my new e-mail client for home / private mail usage.
For work I will probably stick with Outlook for the Exchange integration and that's probably just how Microsoft intends it to be.

If it doesn't get back the ads in the interface this will be the new default mail client for a lot of people.

Where do I get it ?

It seems not every browser will show the same ideas.live.com so here is the direct download link:
http://g.live.com/1rebeta/WLMC_EN

Comments

# re: The new Outlook Express / Thunderbird Killer: Windows Live Mail (Desktop)

Monday, May 14, 2007 3:56 AM by Rob Tillie

Does it support newsgroups? I think outlook express is the only client from MS that supports newsgroups?

# re: The new Outlook Express / Thunderbird Killer: Windows Live Mail (Desktop)

Monday, May 14, 2007 4:22 AM by Mischa Kroon

Yes it supports newsgroups :)

# re: Review - The new Outlook Express / Thunderbird Killer: Windows Live Mail (Desktop)

Thursday, May 31, 2007 6:30 PM by Frank Lindner

Will it be possible to interchange (import "and" export) MailAccounts and Contacts between Windows Live Mail Desktop and Outlook?

# re: Review - The new Outlook Express / Thunderbird Killer: Windows Live Mail (Desktop)

Saturday, June 02, 2007 12:25 PM by Mischa Kroon

Import yes, Export I haven't looked into.

# re: Review - The new Outlook Express / Thunderbird Killer: Windows Live Mail (Desktop)

Wednesday, July 11, 2007 3:58 PM by FyberOptyx

I have tried it for a while now. Nice idea but VERY slow checking my mail, seems buggy checking for spam.

There are many niggles with it, lets hope they fix them and i will return from Thunderbird

# re: Review - The new Outlook Express / Thunderbird Killer: Windows Live Mail (Desktop)

Friday, August 03, 2007 11:13 PM by JennyMax

I'm happy with Thunderbird

# re: Review - The new Outlook Express / Thunderbird Killer: Windows Live Mail (Desktop)

Sunday, February 03, 2008 2:51 AM by cristiano

..hmm... i don't think that it is a killer of thunderbird...

It has a nice appearance, but it is so slow... why? is it written in .net languages?

# re: Review - The new Outlook Express / Thunderbird Killer: Windows Live Mail (Desktop)

Friday, April 18, 2008 10:41 PM by Martin Bruny

Thunderbird is a dog, simply because it doesn't have an Outbox. What kind of idiot makes an email client without a proper delayed outbox, one that only sends mail when I _choose_ to pick up my mail?

# re: Review - The new Outlook Express / Thunderbird Killer: Windows Live Mail (Desktop)

Friday, April 25, 2008 3:10 PM by Chris Howard

Thunderbird may not come with an Outbox but you can easily create one.

Just  right click in a blank area of the folder pane and select New Folder. Call this 'Outbox'.

Now go into Tools/Options/Advanced/Config Editor and navigate to

'mail.default_sendlater_uri'. Right click on this and select Modify.

Type in:   mailbox://youraccount/Outbox

where youraccount is of the form joebloggs@isp.com

Note: you will need to do this for each account.

# re: Review - The new Outlook Express / Thunderbird Killer: Windows Live Mail (Desktop)

Wednesday, May 07, 2008 6:36 PM by Leo

I really really like WLM, especially its formatting of outgoing mails and rendering of unicode header/body. But it still has a fatal bug with use of the hotmail account, that I cannot dump my OE yet. That is, if you set your own reply address, and reply to an email, add bcc: to some other address, then the recipients (both the to: and bcc:) will get emails with corrupted headers, and it exposes the bcc: in the body.

Microsoft acknowledged this bug but says it is "by design". I am so sad to this response.

# re: Review - The new Outlook Express / Thunderbird Killer: Windows Live Mail (Desktop)

Friday, July 04, 2008 9:19 PM by Roger

You must be joking! WLM is buggy rubbish compared to Outlook Express.

# re: Review - The new Outlook Express / Thunderbird Killer: Windows Live Mail (Desktop)

Saturday, October 11, 2008 6:27 PM by ABC

Use off color scheme's

Should be:

Use of color schemes

Now come on!

# re: Review - The new Outlook Express / Thunderbird Killer: Windows Live Mail (Desktop)

Sunday, November 09, 2008 11:31 AM by Michel J. Gaudet

This is 'off-topic', but I can't find another place that might be able to help me.

When we LAUNCH a mail program, we first see the IN-BOX or what ever AREA we have set to have pop-up first.  I want to change the BACKGROUND from WHITE to a darker color.  EVERY, I mean EVERY search for this tells me how to change the background for a MESSAGE, which I have been doing for years; have stationary for special occasions.  I just want to set what I would THINK would be called the Outlook Express 'COLOR SCHEME'.  Any suggestions?

Leave a Comment

(required) 
(required) 
(optional)
(required)